Updated October 17, 2026 · TariffCue Editorial Team
Budget Energie vs sim.de
Budget Energie vs sim.de: the differences
| Compare | ||
|---|---|---|
| Host network | KPN | 1&1 |
| Price from | €3.75Lower | €6.99 |
| Reference plan prices | 3GB: EUR 3.75 per month, 3GB, 24 months; 30GB: EUR 5.25 per month, 30GB, 24 months; Unlimited: EUR 10 per month, unlimited, 24 months | 25 GB: 6.99 EUR/month, 25 GB, 1 month; 50 GB: 9.99 EUR/month, 50 GB, 24 months; Unlimited on demand: 19.99 EUR/month, unlimited, 24 months |
| Unlimited plan price | €10Lower | €19.99 |
| EU roaming | Fair use | Included |
| Roaming countries | 43Higher | 33 |
| Markets | NL | DE |
| eSIM | Not confirmed | Yes |
Same on both: Seller type (Mvno), SIM-only (Yes), 5G (Yes).
We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings.
Key differences
- Budget Energie scores higher overall: 9.0 vs 8.9.
- Price from is lower at Budget Energie: €3.75 vs €6.99.
- Unlimited plan price is lower at Budget Energie: €10 vs €19.99.
- Roaming countries is higher at Budget Energie: 43 vs 33.
- Founded is lower at Budget Energie: 2011 vs 2014.
- Billing: only sim.de offers Rolling.
- Contract length: only Budget Energie offers 12.
- Contract length: only sim.de offers 1.
- Markets: only Budget Energie offers NL.
- Markets: only sim.de offers DE.
Our verdict on each
Budget Energie
Budget Energie suits Dutch households that want electricity and gas from a single supplier and want to choose how the price moves. Its green tariff is backed by 100% renewable certificates, and the business has grown to 1,000,000 customers since it was founded in 2011.
sim.de
sim.de suits people in Germany who want a cheap sim only line with a monthly option and a fixed contract choice on the same tariff sheet. It runs on the 1&1 network, and its entry price of €6.99 sits well under the market median for entry pricing.
Score breakdown
| Area | Budget Energie | sim.de |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Not confirmed | 9.1Entry at €6.99 and unlimited at €19.99 both sit under the site medians of €9.30 and €23.19. |
| Offer | 9.3Higherfixed, variable and dynamic all available, electricity and gas on one account, fixed terms 12 and 36 months. | 9.0Sim only, 5G and Esim are available, with included roaming across 33 countries and terms of 1 and 24. |
| Trust | 8.4Registered in NL as Budget Thuis B.V., trading since 2011, with support on email, chat and phone. | 8.4Run by Drillisch Online GmbH since 2014, an mvno on the 1&1 network with support on email, chat and phone. |
The numbers side by side
| Fact | Budget Energie | sim.de |
|---|---|---|
| Price from | €3.75 | €6.99 |
| Unlimited plan price | €10 | €19.99 |
| Roaming countries | 43 | 33 |
How they place
| Ranking | Budget Energie | sim.de |
|---|---|---|
| SIM-only deals | 18 of 416 | 24 of 416 |
| Cheap cell phone plans (MVNOs) | 10 of 137 | 14 of 137 |
| Broadband providers | 5 of 124 | 7 of 124 |
| Full fibre providers | 4 of 107 | 6 of 107 |
Every fact side by side
| Fact | Budget Energie | sim.de |
|---|---|---|
| Billing | Contract | Contract, RollingCovers more |
| Contract length | 12, 24 | 1, 24 |
| Legal entity | Budget Thuis B.V. | Drillisch Online GmbH |
| Headquarters | Netherlands | Germany |
| Founded | 2011Lower | 2014 |
| Support channels | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre |
Broadband
| Fact | Budget Energie | sim.de |
|---|---|---|
| Technology | Fttp, Fttc | Fttc, Fttp |
| Top download speed (Mbps) | 1,000 | 1,000 |
| Upload speed (Mbps) | 1,000Higher | 5.8 to 40 |
| Setup fee | €0Lower | €49.99 |
| Exit fee terms | 1 month notice; early termination costs charged on final bill | Not confirmed |
| Router | Nokia Beacon G3.1 or Draytek Vigor | FRITZ!Box 7510, 7630 or 7690, from 4.99 EUR per month, optional |
| Address checker | https://www.budgetthuis.nl/internet | https://www.sim.de/glasfaser |
Where each stands against the rest
| Fact | Budget Energie | sim.de | Median |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price from | €3.75below the median | €6.99above the median | €5 |
| Unlimited plan price | €10lowest quarter | €19.99at the median | €19.99 |
| Roaming countries | 43below the median | 33lowest quarter | 100 |
Median across 176 listed providers.
Pros and cons
Budget Energie
Pros
- Tariff choice runs wide, with fixed, variable and dynamic under a single name.
- Green power is 100% renewable, backed by certificates.
- Fixed terms run 12 and 36 months, so there is a date to plan around.
Cons
- The exit fee terms ask for notice, and early termination costs land on the final bill.
- Service is limited to NL, so it is not an option for a household outside the Netherlands.
- Electricity Ratings lists fixed, ev and time of use, adding electric vehicle and prepay tariffs that sit outside fixed, variable and dynamic.
sim.de
Pros
- Entry pricing of €6.99 is below the site median of €9.30
- The Unlimited on demand plan costs €19.99, under the site median unlimited price of €23.19
- Contract terms run 1 and 24, so a plan can sit on a monthly term or a longer one
Cons
- The Unlimited on demand plan is tied to the longer of 1 and 24, so unlimited data is not offered on a monthly term
- Service runs in DE only, so the tariffs are not offered outside that market
- As an mvno, sim.de sells on the 1&1 network rather than owning it, unlike the network operators getesa, yesss! and Lonestar Cell MTN
Who each suits
Budget Energie
Who it suits
- Households that want power and gas under a single contract instead of juggling separate suppliers.
- Households that want a spread of tariff types, since Budget Energie lists fixed, variable and dynamic.
- People who prefer a phone line and chat to a single contact route, and who want dynamic and green options rather than the fixed, time of use and ev list at Endesa.
Who should look elsewhere
- Electricity Ratings, if you need an electric vehicle or prepay tariff, since fixed, ev and time of use runs wider than fixed, variable and dynamic.
- Endesa, if you only want fixed, time-of-use or electric vehicle pricing, because Endesa lists fixed, time of use and ev.
sim.de
Who it suits
- People in DE who want a data heavy sim only line without paying for a handset
- Travellers from DE who want roaming included and reach across 33 countries
- Households that want one provider offering both a short monthly term and a longer fixed contract
Who should look elsewhere
- Buyers outside DE, since the service is a single market
- People who want a handset bundled with the tariff, as the plans are sim only
- Buyers who want unlimited data on a rolling monthly basis, since the Unlimited on demand plan sits on the longer of 1 and 24
Country by country
| Country | Budget Energie | sim.de |
|---|---|---|
| Netherlands | Yes | No |
Questions about each
Budget Energie
What tariff types does Budget Energie offer?+
Budget Energie sells fixed, variable and dynamic tariffs, so a household can choose between a price that holds for a set term and one that follows the market, plus a dynamic option and a green option. The spread means you can start on a fixed deal and change type at renewal without moving supplier, and it keeps the door open if your usage pattern changes.
How long are the fixed terms?+
Fixed terms run 12 and 36 months, which gives you a date to plan around. Take the shorter term if you expect prices to move your way and want the chance to switch sooner; take the longer term if you would rather not revisit the decision each year. The variable and dynamic tariffs carry no fixed end date.
sim.de
How much does a sim.de sim only plan cost to start with?+
The cheapest way in is the entry data plan at €6.99 per month, and it can run on a monthly term rather than a long contract. The larger data plan and the Unlimited on demand plan sit on the longer of 1 and 24 instead.
How much is unlimited data on sim.de?+
The Unlimited on demand plan costs €19.99 per month, and it is tied to the longer of the contract options, 1 and 24. That price sits under the site median unlimited price of €23.19, but the commitment is the part to weigh.
Other options to compare
Other matchups
- Budget Energie vs Eon Next
- Budget Energie vs Abissnet
- Budget Energie vs EarthLink
- Budget Energie vs Kinetic
- sim.de vs RED by SFR
- sim.de vs hollandsnieuwe
- sim.de vs Odido Thuis
- sim.de vs toob
- sim.de vs Frontier Communications
- sim.de vs OiSTER
- sim.de vs Optimum
- Budget Energie vs YouFibre
- Budget Energie vs Astound
- Budget Energie vs MobileX
- Budget Energie vs yallo
- Budget Energie vs Lycamobile
- Budget Energie vs nju Mobile
- Budget Energie vs Twigby Mobile
- sim.de vs Budget Thuis Internet
- sim.de vs ho. Mobile
- Budget Energie vs PremiumSIM
- Budget Energie vs 1pMobile
- Budget Energie vs Lyca Mobile
- sim.de vs Eni Plenitude
- Budget Energie vs EE Store
- Budget Energie vs Singtel
- Budget Energie vs beeline
- Budget Energie vs Vectra